Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC: A Double-Edged Sword of Difficulty and Praise
While Shadow of the Erdtree has received critical acclaim, its Steam reception is more nuanced, revealing a divide among players regarding its difficulty and performance.
Related Video
Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree - Falling Short of Expectations?
Shadow of the Erdtree: A Brutal Reality Check for Players
Steam Reviews Reveal a Divided Playerbase
Despite pre-release Metacritic accolades, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree launched to a wave of mixed player reviews on Steam. Released June 21st, the DLC's challenging gameplay is praised, but many express frustration with intense combat, perceived difficulty imbalances, and performance issues across PC and consoles.
Performance and Difficulty: Key Sources of Criticism
The expansion's demanding battles are a major point of contention. Players report fights feeling significantly harder than the base game, with some citing "rushed" enemy placement and excessively high boss health pools.
Performance problems further compound the issue. PC users report crashes, micro-stuttering, and frame rate limitations. Even high-end systems experience frame drops below 30 FPS in crowded areas, impacting playability. Similar frame rate drops during intense moments have been reported on PlayStation consoles.
As of Monday, Steam shows a "Mixed" overall rating for Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, with 36% negative reviews. Metacritic presents a more positive "Generally Favorable" rating of 8.3/10 (based on 570 user reviews), while Game8 gives it a 94/100 rating. This discrepancy highlights the stark difference in player experience.
